Vote Swapping and Why I Am Considering It

A common school of thought around election time is that of “There is no point in voting because my vote doesn’t count”; people feel that their voice isn’t heard, particularly if they live in a “safe seat” or an area where the battle for power is between two candidates, neither of whom particularly appeal.

Tactical voting has been around for years. You know the idea; don’t necessarily vote for the party whose policies most closely relate to your views or desires for the country but vote in a way to try to ensure the current party gets removed from (or stays in) power. Vote swapping is simply another element of tactical voting and enables your voice to be heard, albeit not necessarily in your constituency.

Take for example, the Labour held seat of East Ham. Labour are expected to hold on to the seat but with a huge majority of over 60%, if you are a Labour voter, you may worry that your vote will be wasted, that perhaps it would be put to better use elsewhere. At the other end of the scale is Norwich North. Current predictions show that Labour are expected to take this seat from Conservatives with the smallest of margins, less than 1%. If you are a Green voter here, your vote is effectively a vote for the Conservatives due to the nature of the first past the post system we have.

vote

So, what can you do?

Well, in the case above the person who lives in East Ham may well be prepared to ‘swap’ their vote with the person in Norwich North so instead of voting for Labour they can pledge to vote for Green and vice versa. This will give Labour a better chance of taking the Norwich North seat from Conservatives. People can vote tactically with the knowledge that their preferred vote is still being used.

Enter in two websites. VoteSwap has a clear political agenda; it was set up purely to help Labour and Green voters to work together with the aim of removing the Conservatives from power. Here, users enter in their constituency and are then advised which way to vote to make the best use of their vote to remove Conservatives and then pledge to vote the relevant way. SwapMyVote on the other hand, has no political agenda; users can select who their preferred party is (out of all major parties) and who they are prepared to vote for. They are then matched with another person and are encouraged to contact one another through social media, each user pledges to vote for the other person’s party of choice.

I hope the above has made sense? It makes sense in my head but explaining it feels a whole lot more tricky!

Personally, I am still not sure about how I feel about vote swapping. It saddens me that it currently seems to be the only way for so many people to use the power of their vote in the most effective manner, it doesn’t feel all that ethical (although it is perfectly legal). At the same time, people have being voting tactically for years so one is also inclined to think “What’s the problem?”. There is also the thinking that if everyone actually voted for the parties who they believe in then perhaps we would see a shift from our current system which still feels very much a two party battle. Despite all of these thoughts, it IS something I am considering. I feel that vote-swapping (rather than simply pledging to vote differently) is the most effective way to get my voice heard, albeit in an area I do not live in. Where I live, over 60% of votes were effectively discarded in 2010, that is less than 40% of voters actually voted for the winner; that’s enough to make anyone feel rather disheartened.

With less than two weeks to go until the election, I have a whole lot more thinking to do.

What do you think of vote-swapping? Do you live in an area where your preferred vote would count for little and if so would you consider pledging to vote for a different party? I’d love to know your thoughts (particularly as I am being interviewed on Monday morning around this discussion)!

 

8 thoughts on “Vote Swapping and Why I Am Considering It

  1. I think any form of tactical voting is wrong To be honest. If everyone voted, instead of sitting on their backsides complaining about how awful the government is, then they should vote. If everyone voted, then it would be a fair, Democratic approach. But because people think that their vote will be wasted, they don’t bother Attending the polling station to vote. those Those “safe seats” may not be so safe if everyone actually took part. People should vote for the party or individual they wish to have representing them for their area. As you can probably tell, I wholeheartedly disagree with this concept! Xx
    Steph recently posted…My First… BoyMy Profile

    1. Excellent point actually that ‘safe seats’ may not be so safe if everyone actually voted how they would prefer to vote. Another issue (for me at least) is that while I think my local MP is great and has achieved a lot, I cannot bring myself to vote for her because of the party policies. x

  2. Wow, this is something I was totally unaware of, but it’s a really interesting idea and seems to make a lot of sense. The first past the post system will always means our votes aren’t entirely representative of people’s views and maybe this goes a little way towards changing things.
    I’ve always voted tactically and am now at the point where my ‘tactical’ party is probably my preferred party.
    Good luck with your interview today!
    sarahmo3w recently posted…The cheese issueMy Profile

  3. I must admit that I hate the idea of vote swapping. In fact I hate tactical voting fullstop. I can’t help but think that if *everyone* voted for who they actually wanted to, much more of us would be happy with the overall result. I think the biggest problem right now is people not voting at all. For such a huge percentage of our nation to have a say by *not* voting maddens me beyond belief.
    (Mostly) Yummy Mummy recently posted…17 today!My Profile

    1. Oh don’t get me started on those that don’t vote. In 2010 65% of those registered to vote, DID vote which is up on the previous two general elections; we can only hope this trend continues. The preferred option is definitely that everyone votes for who they want to but it is an issue that a lot of people feel unable to do so or that it is a waste to.

  4. Gosh Rachel, I had never heard of this! It feels a bit sly to me but I’m not sure why; probably because I like to abide by the rules! I’m more confused than ever before over this election. So hard to vote well. I hope your interview went ok. When will we see you on TV?
    suzanne3childrenandit recently posted…Best Friends ForeverMy Profile

  5. I had no idea this existed, love the idea because it’s forcing folk to think outside the box (quite literally!) I think the key to change is getting the people who weren’t going to vote to actually do so. And thinking about it now, I reckon a Labour-Green coalition would work really well… I can’t believe voting day is in just over a week, how did that happen?! Thanks for sharing this hon xx
    Mummy Tries recently posted…Do You Want to be a Better Parent?My Profile

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.